September 2, 2026 · 5 min read
A settlement can be entirely real, correctly claimed, and still hand you something you did not want. The benefit type is stated in the notice and almost nobody reads it before filing.
| Form | What it means | Catch |
|---|---|---|
| Cheque | Mailed to the address on your claim. | Goes stale. Cash it: an uncashed cheque is often redistributed. |
| E-transfer / direct deposit | Increasingly common in Canada. | Watch for phishing that imitates it. Confirm the sender against the administrator's site. |
| Account credit | Applied to your account with the defendant. | Worth nothing if you have left the service. |
| Voucher / coupon | Store credit, often with an expiry and conditions. | Requires spending money with the company that was sued. |
| Free product or service | Replacement goods, or credit monitoring after a breach. | Credit monitoring is real value only if you actually enrol. |
A coupon settlement lets a defendant post a large headline number while paying in discounts that drive further sales. Courts have grown sceptical of them for exactly that reason, and approval increasingly depends on the class receiving something with real cash value.
You will still meet them. When you do, the honest way to read the number is: a $30 voucher requiring a $100 purchase is not $30.
Nearly every data breach settlement offers it, and it has genuine value, but only to someone who enrols and uses it. It is offered because it is inexpensive per person at scale and demonstrably responsive to the harm.
Take it if you were affected. Just do not read "two years of credit monitoring" as the cash part of the settlement.
The claim form increasingly asks you to pick a rail rather than just an address. In Canada that usually means Interac e-Transfer against a cheque; in US settlements the menu is longer and often includes PayPal, Venmo, Zelle, a direct deposit, or a virtual prepaid card.
Treat the card option with more care than the others. A prepaid card is spendable money, but it can carry its own terms: an expiry date, conditions on how a remaining balance is used, and in some cases inactivity handling. None of that applies to a deposit into your own account. If the form offers a bank transfer and a card for the same amount, they are not equivalent offers.
The digital options also have a plain advantage worth naming: they cannot be undeliverable because you moved, which is the way most valid claims quietly turn into no money.
Settlement cheques are commonly printed with a validity window, and separately, financial institutions generally treat a cheque as stale once it is around six months old and can decline it. A settlement cheque sitting in a drawer is not money waiting for you. It is money on its way back to the fund.
If yours has gone stale, ask the administrator about reissue immediately rather than at your convenience. Many will reissue inside a window that the settlement itself defines, and once that window closes the answer stops being yes.
Very few settlements return unclaimed funds to the defendant, and the notice will say what happens instead. The usual paths are a second distribution to claimants who did file, or a cy-près direction, where remaining money goes to an organisation the court approves as connected to the class.
Two things follow from that. Your payment can be larger than the estimate if the claim rate is low, which is the same mechanism running in your favour rather than against you. And an uncashed cheque is not neutral: it becomes part of the residual, so leaving it is a decision about someone else's money as well as your own.
Every one of these is disclosed in the notice, and the claim form is where an irreversible choice gets made. Three minutes on these questions is the highest-value part of filing:
We record what a settlement actually delivers rather than flattening everything into a dollar figure, and a settlement that offers a voucher is not presented as though it offered cash. Where a notice does not state the benefit, we show nothing rather than assume: a data breach settlement is not credit monitoring unless the notice says so.
Only where the settlement offers both, which some do. The claim form is where that choice is made, and it cannot be changed afterwards.
Ask the administrator quickly. Many will reissue within a window, after which uncashed funds move to the settlement's residual distribution.
Check the sender against the administrator named on the settlement's official site before accepting. And no legitimate settlement ever asks you to pay a fee, buy a card, or hand over a password to release a payment.
See what is open now, and what each one pays →
PayUpBro is not a law firm and never files a claim for you. This page explains publicly available information about how class action settlements work; it is not legal advice. Whether you qualify is decided by the court-appointed settlement administrator, not by us.